Mistakes Read Amen That Cancels Salat Prayers

Mistakes Read Amen that Cancels the salat Prayers

Question :
How to read the correct Amin and whether there is a wrong amen reading, which can cause the prayer to be null and void.





Answer:

Bismillah was shalatu was salam' ala Rasulillah, wa ba'du,

According to the famous opinion among linguists, there are 2 ways to read the correct amen.

[First] is read extending the word ' Aa ... ', so it becomes Aaamiiin ...

[Second] is read by shortening the word ' A ... ' so that it becomes Amiin ...

Here are some of the scholars' information about this,

[1] Al-Hafidz Ibn Hajar's statement,



Takmin is the masdar form of the word ' Ammna ' with mim -tasydid, which means reading amiin. And all the narrations and scholars of the Koran mention the reading by extending hamzah or shortening the hamzah. 

[2] Ibn Abdil Barr's description,



when reciting amee-n, there are two ways to read, extend and shorten, such as Awah and Aaawah. 

[3] Description of an-Nawawi,



In the amiin recitation, there are 2 ways of reciting, extended and shortened. Which is extended more eloquently. And both the letters mim are not tasydid. 

Recite Wrong Amin 

Shaykh Dr. Abdullah az-Zahim mentioned several ways reciting the wrong Amin.

First, amen reading errors that cause prayer to be nullified by agreeing with the ulama

[1] Hamzah was extended, mim in tasydid, and the letter 'ya' was omitted, so that it became Aaamm min [آمّن].

[2] Hamzah is read short, mim is in tasydid, and the letter 'ya' is omitted, so that it becomes Amm min [أمّن].

[3] Hamzah is read short, mim is not tasydid, and the letter 'ya' is omitted, so that it becomes Amen [أَمِنْ].

Second, the amen error agreed upon by the ulama,

but whether it cancels or not, there is a difference between the scholars. The sound of this amen reading is to shorten the hamzah, mim in tasydid, and there is the letter 'ya'. so read: Ammmiiin [آمِّيْن]

The ulamas agreed, this kind of ameen prohibited, but they disagreed, whether canceling prayer or not. Syafiiyah rate, this does not cancel prayer. While other schools judge this can cancel prayer.

Third, the error of the reading of Aameen's disputed is whether it is permissible and the prayer is canceled

[1] Hamzah was extended, mim in tasydid, and there was a letter 'ya'. so read: Aaam miiiin [آمِّيْن]

Hanafiyah allows this kind of error. While the jumhur prohibits it.

It's just that, according to Syafiiyah, this kind of amen does not cancel prayer. While Hambali and Malikiyah rate, this amen recitation can cancel salah prayer.

[2] Hamzah is extended, mim is not tasydid, and the letter 'ya' is discarded, so read: 'Aaamin' [آمن].

Some Hanafis allow this kind of amen, but are not mentioned by other schools. And the truth is, this is prohibited.

So Hopefully useful ...

Thus, Allahu a’lam.



This post Link (For references): 
https://yourdakwah.blogspot.com/2018/10/mistakes-read-amen-that-cancels-salat.html

Read Also :
Law of Looting/stealing When Disaster
The Law of Taking Fruit on a Roadside Tree
The Law of Selling on Sidewalks